WARNING: SPOILER ALERT!
Spoilers occur below!
[note: I wrote this about 6 months ago, but due to a request, am only posting it now.]
If you have not seen Pan's Labyrinth, then don't read this blog entry for now. See the movie any way you can and then come back and read this. "I may not want to see that movie", you might say. Well, what if you learn something here that makes you change your mind? Then I screwed you out of some of the magic that the film delivers in abundance. I don't want to do that to you. See Pan's Labyrinth, because it's one of the best movies I've ever seen.
Reasons to see it:
-It is an awesome fantasy film, on par with the Lord of the Rings trilogy
-It has some vivid, graphic violence [OMG!]
-It has monster[s] that you will not soon forget.
-It won 3 Oscars. It won 3 Oscars. It won 3 Oscars.
Reasons not to see it:
-If you can't hang with subtitles (Spanish movie, no dubbing).
-If you can't deal with realistic [though fleeting] violence.
Mood: Constant tension, punctuated by random ultra-violent moments. This film is hard to describe in a few words. It is a fantasy film about a world inhabited by fairies and fauns and nightmarish monsters, but it is also a lesson in Spanish history (the movie is in Spanish, with English subtitles for us buffoons) and an extremely violent and cruel history at that, personified by a very malevolent, fascist military man, Captain Vidal, one of the most atrocious, psychotic onscreen villains of all time. There are two main stories unfolding in the movie: Ofelia's real world and her "fantasy world", which it turns out is not a fantasy at all (in my opinion, after much reflection, more below).
The thing that will linger with me the longest from that movie is a creature referred to in the credits as the "Pale Man". The Pale Man is an impossible, horrifying abomination with eyes in the palms of his hands who waits for untold ages for a child to happen along, which he devours. One has to ask, even in Ofelia's fantasy world, was the Pale Man even real? The Pale man was played by the same actor who played the faun, American actor Doug Jones (Abe Sapien from Hellboy, another film by Guillermo Del Toro...incidentally, Jones learned Spanish for the part of the faun, but in the end, his voice was replaced in post production by a different actor). The Pale Man kills two fairies during Ofelia's visit to his lair. (In much the same way you would dispatch a vienna sausage.) Those two fairies later accompany the faun when Ofelia is greeted in the Underworld, suggesting they weren't really killed after all, and Jones was in both costumes for more than just his incredible skill. My current opinion: The faun was creating the illusion of the Pale Man, with his fairies as accomplices, for the purpose of Ofelia's second test - dealing with temptation.
Ofelia was warned early on by Mercedes that Mercedes' mother once told her to be wary of fauns. The faun is being a trickster, but never for the reasons that seem apparent. Only at the very end, is his true role exposed. He never would have harmed the baby; he didn't really allow his precious fairies to get killed.
The Pale Man lives in a sealed-in lair. The only way in or out is apparently a magic door created with chalk supplied by the faun. It would seem at first that the faun has done this countless times to test other hopefuls, but would the faun really send all those children to their deaths? Nonsense. That would defy the philosophy of the Underworld of which he is a court member (peace and love and eternal life and happiness). Who painted the murals depicting the Pale Man's gruesome history on the ceiling? The Pale Man? The faun? I think now the whole scene was an elaborate, magical setup by the faun. Maybe I just don't want the thing to be real, even in the movie. I have to admit, that thing creeped me out more than anything I've seen in a movie in decades, and that's no bullshite.
The frog (which lives in the roots of a tree that looks vaguely like the faun's head) from the first task was probably a setup too. The Pale Man's locker key in the frog's stomach? Come On, faun! Then the faun using the Pale Man's knife, seen in the murals where he is stabbing kids, to draw the blood of an innocent? Convenient, eh?
No, the real monster in the movie is Captain Vidal (no. 39 in 100 Greatest movie villains list, btw]. What an EVIL BASTARD! Holy crap that guy is just totally evil and psychotic. It took 2 viewings to start to get a grip on that character. His psychosis is deep. He's obsessed, anally-retentive, and totally evil. Thank God he got his. I'd like to see a death match between Pale Man and Vidal. Vidal would win, of course...evil scumbag. (Captain Vidal would wipe his ass with Dennis Hopper as Frank Booth from Blue Velvet, btw.)
Supposedly, there is a comic coming out about the backstory of the Pale Man. That suggests that he was a real thing in the "fantasy world" and perhaps not an illusion by the faun. Fauns are known for being untrustworthy tricksters, so maybe Pale Man really was some goon called upon by the faun on occaision. I get ill just contemplating it.
Fantasy world not real?
-Vidal apparently cannot see the faun, while he is still there talking to Ofelia at the end...unless the faun can control who can and cannot see him...or you have to believe in fauns to see them or something.
Fantasy world real?
-Ofelia escapes from her LOCKED room - via magic chalk door?
-At the beginning (rest of movie is flashback), Ofelia's bloody nose gets unbloodied, presumably just before her father rouses her into the Underworld (at the end).
-The labyrinth is really there (acknowledged by other characters) and actually shifts/moves at end to allow Ofelia more time in her escape from Vidal (a scene very much like end of The Shining)...Vidal has to backtrack and take the long route or scale a wall or something.
What did you think of the movie?